Share
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Pinterest
Reddit
Digg
Tumblr
Email
Let me tell you about a conversation I had recently with a West Auckland manufacturer who’s been running his family business for thirty-odd years. “Steve,” he said, nursing his flat white like it contained the secret to economic salvation, “everyone keeps telling me Auckland’s recovering. But I’m looking at my order book, and I’m not seeing it.”
He’s not alone. While ASB’s latest Regional Economic Scoreboard shows Auckland displaying “signs of recovery” in the June 2025 quarter, the reality on Queen Street feels rather different. It’s a classic case of statistical noise masquerading as meaningful momentum – and it’s time we called it what it is.
Auckland’s recent performance in the scoreboard represents an improvement from its dismal 14th-place ranking in the September 2024 quarter, where it had “fallen from 9th to 14th” with housing sales sitting at -0.6% compared to the national average of 7.4%. But here’s the rub: showing “signs of recovery” from terrible performance isn’t the same as genuine economic momentum – it’s statistical relief masquerading as progress.
The unemployment picture tells a starker story. While New Zealand’s national unemployment rate hit 5.2% in June 2025, Auckland’s jobless rate soared to 6.1%, representing a brutal 1.5 percentage point increase from the previous year. That’s 23,100 fewer Aucklanders in employment year-on-year. These aren’t statistics – they’re families struggling to pay the mortgage in Manukau, young graduates moving back in with their parents in Pakuranga, and experienced professionals wondering if they’ll ever find work that matches their skills.
Meanwhile, the United States – our second-largest export destination worth $9 billion annually – has slapped a 15% tariff on New Zealand goods, up from the initial 10%. For Auckland’s port-dependent economy, this isn’t just an inconvenience; it’s a structural headwind that demands serious strategic thinking, not wishful optimism.
Auckland Council’s Annual Plan for 2025/2026 commits $385 million to community capital projects and $1.25 billion to water infrastructure through Watercare. On paper, that looks impressive. The council is spending big on the basics – roads, pipes, stormwater systems. But are we building for today’s problems or tomorrow’s opportunities?
Auckland Transport’s capital programme has been slashed from $1.459 billion to $1.352 million after the government’s National Land Transport Plan allocated less funding for Auckland. This funding cut arrives precisely when we need bold infrastructure investment to support genuine economic transformation, not just maintenance of the status quo.
Here’s where my background in economics gets uncomfortable with the official optimism. Infrastructure spending should be countercyclical – you invest more when the private sector is struggling, not less. Yet we’re seeing the opposite: reduced transport investment when unemployment is rising and businesses are crying out for productivity improvements.
Heart of the City chief executive Viv Beck captured the frustration perfectly with a statement to Radio NZ: “If the government doesn’t want to do [a bed levy], what we need is a discussion about what the alternatives are… we could actually end up with a plan of attack.” Business leaders aren’t asking for handouts; they’re begging for a plan.
The Auckland Tech Council has produced a comprehensive strategy to make Auckland “a global tech hub,” calling for “supercharged public and private investment” and “urgent action and partnership across business, government, city leadership, and academia.” It’s exactly the kind of forward-thinking approach we need. But where’s the government’s response? Where’s the matching commitment from Wellington?
Auckland’s path to genuine recovery requires three fundamental shifts that go beyond quarterly statistical improvements:
First, we need productivity-focused infrastructure investment. Not just maintaining roads, but building the digital backbone and transport connections that enable businesses to compete globally. Auckland Council has committed over $26 billion of investment between 2018 and 2028, including the $4.4 billion City Rail Link. But are we connecting these investments to measurable productivity outcomes?
Second, we must embrace Auckland’s role as New Zealand’s innovation hub. With 37% of the country’s population and GDP, Auckland should be punching above its weight in high-value sectors. The tech council’s vision isn’t pie-in-the-sky thinking – it’s economic necessity.
Third, we need honest conversations about our global positioning. With New Zealand wine facing an additional NZ$112 million in annual tariffs to the US market alone, we can’t rely on traditional export patterns. Auckland needs to become the bridge between New Zealand innovation and global markets, not just a distribution point for primary products.
My West Auckland manufacturer friend ended our conversation with a challenge: “Stop telling me we’re recovering and show me how we’re preparing for what comes next.” He’s right. Real economic leadership isn’t about managing decline gracefully or celebrating marginal improvements. It’s about creating the conditions for sustainable, high-value growth.
Auckland business leaders have put forward specific proposals. The tech sector has outlined a clear strategy. Council has allocated substantial capital investment. What we’re missing is the political will to connect these pieces into a coherent economic development strategy.
The city of sails needs more than favourable wind statistics – it needs a navigation plan that acknowledges the storms ahead while charting a course toward genuine prosperity. The question isn’t whether Auckland is recovering from yesterday’s challenges, but whether we’re preparing for tomorrow’s opportunities.
Until we answer that honestly, we’ll continue mistaking statistical noise for economic substance, and our unemployment queues will keep growing while other regions race ahead.
Steve Baron is a New Zealand-based political commentator and author. He holds a BA with a double major in Economics and Political Science from the University of Waikato and an Honours Degree in Political Science from Victoria University of Wellington. A former businessman in the advertising industry, he founded the political lobby group Better Democracy NZ. https://stevebaron.co.nz
Karl says:
Spot on Steve. Running a small logistics company in South Auckland and can confirm – the “recovery” stats don’t match what I’m seeing with customers. Lost two major contracts this quarter alone. We need real action, not just council meetings about bed levies. The US tariff hit is already biting hard for my manufacturing clients. Less chat about how we’re doing compared to last year’s disaster, more focus on actually building something sustainable.